Few things frustrate readers more than a glaring plot hole—an inconsistency, contradiction, or logic gap that pulls them out of the story. Even the best writers can fall victim to plot holes, but the good news is that most of them can be fixed with a little attention to detail. Whether you’re writing your first novel or fine-tuning a draft, the following information will help you identify common plot holes and, more importantly, show you how to repair them before they sink your story.
Contents
What Exactly Is a Plot Hole?
A plot hole is any inconsistency in a story that disrupts its logic, breaks immersion, or contradicts established facts. These gaps can range from minor errors that cause mild confusion to massive inconsistencies that make a story completely fall apart.
Common Types of Plot Holes
- Contradictions: When a story contradicts itself, such as a character knowing information they shouldn’t or a rule being broken without explanation.
- Improbable Events: When something highly unlikely happens with no justification, making the story feel unrealistic.
- Continuity Errors: When details change between scenes without explanation (e.g., a character’s injury disappearing).
- Unresolved Questions: When a major plot point is introduced but never addressed again.
- Broken World-Building: When established rules of the world are ignored or changed arbitrarily.
Plot Holes That Can Derail Your Story
Characters Who Magically Know Things
Have you ever read a book where a character suddenly knows a crucial piece of information they were never told? It’s a frustrating oversight that can make readers feel cheated.
How to Fix It:
- Ensure that every piece of knowledge a character possesses has been earned within the story.
- Use dialogue, flashbacks, or past events to naturally introduce the information.
- If necessary, add a scene where they learn the missing detail.
Breaking the Rules of Your Own World
Whether you’re writing fantasy, sci-fi, or contemporary fiction, every story has rules. If you establish that magic requires years of training but suddenly have a character mastering it overnight, you’ve created a plot hole.
How to Fix It:
- Write down the rules of your world and stick to them.
- If an exception must be made, provide a solid in-story reason.
- Use foreshadowing to hint at possible rule-breaking in advance.
The Vanishing Subplot
Sometimes a subplot is introduced with great importance, only to disappear completely before the story ends. Readers notice when questions remain unanswered.
How to Fix It:
- Review your draft and make sure all subplots have a resolution.
- If a subplot is no longer relevant, remove its setup early in the story.
- Find ways to integrate the subplot into the main storyline.
Characters Acting Out of Character
When a character suddenly acts in a way that contradicts their established personality for no reason, readers will question the logic behind it.
How to Fix It:
- Ensure character decisions align with their motivations.
- If a major change in behavior is necessary, build up to it gradually.
- Use internal conflict or external pressure to justify their actions.
Impossible Timing and Logistics
Does your character travel across a continent in an hour? Or recover from a life-threatening wound in a day? Inconsistent timing and logistics can break immersion.
How to Fix It:
- Map out travel distances and time realistically.
- Use time skips carefully and make sure they’re clear to the reader.
- Research realistic recovery times for injuries.
The Convenient Coincidence
Nothing kills suspense faster than a coincidence that solves a problem too easily. If a hero escapes danger because a key suddenly appears under a rock, it feels like lazy storytelling.
How to Fix It:
- Replace coincidences with cause-and-effect storytelling.
- If a coincidence must happen, balance it by making the character work for their victory afterward.
How to Catch Plot Holes Before Readers Do
Keep a Story Bible
A story bible is a document that keeps track of all details in your novel—characters, timelines, rules, and settings. This prevents contradictions and inconsistencies.
Read Your Manuscript Like a New Reader
Take a break from your draft and then read it as if you were experiencing the story for the first time. Look for gaps in logic, missing explanations, and inconsistencies.
Use Beta Readers
Other people will spot mistakes you overlook. Beta readers can ask, “Wait, how did they know that?” or “Wasn’t the villain supposed to be dead?”
Ask ‘Why’ and ‘How’ Continuously
Every major plot point should answer two questions: Why does this happen? How does this happen? If you can’t answer both, there may be a plot hole.
Strengthening Your Story
Every writer makes mistakes, but catching and fixing plot holes is what separates a forgettable story from a great one. By maintaining consistency, questioning logic, and staying true to the world you’ve built, you can ensure your novel holds up under scrutiny. The next time you edit your manuscript, keep this guide handy—and make sure your story stays afloat.
